We then headed up a steep trail on the west side of Cement Creek that probably wasn't meant for uphill riding, based on the deep ruts and multiple alternate trails to the top. Our intention was to keep moderately close to Cement Creek Road and eventually work our way back east to American Flag Mountain, but Scott had other ideas. In the lead position, he missed a right turn in the trail and blasted westward on top of a mountain ridge towards Crested Butte at Warp Factor 9. Matt and I watched this happen and debated for half a minute whether we should go after him or wait patiently for him to figure it out on his own. I decided to pursue, which took about 2 miles of Warp Factor 9.5 to catch Scott and casually mention that we might want to turn around before we see ski lifts.
Shortly after crossing back over Cement Creek Road, we let Curtis take a solo tour around Taylor Park for the rest of the day. We really didn’t plan to lose him. In fairness to The Navigator, the point where the three of us voluntarily separated from him was within shouting distance of the Grassy Trail ATV path, Reno Divide Road, Reno Ridge Road, Flag Creek Trail, both the new and old Italian Creek Roads, and what we would soon discover was the steep trail up to the Reno radio repeater. It’s a busy place on the map. Matt thought we were headed for Old Italian Creek Road and a long, steep quasi-jeep trail up loose rock. It was an intimidating sight, to which Curtis said “no thanks.” We sent him towards what we thought was the easier “new” Italian Creek Road, on the map showing convergence with our path a few miles later where the old and new roads met again.
Curtis continued east while the three of us took turns riding straight up face of the mountain, starting at around 11,250 feet and dead-ending a half mile later at 12,100 feet. At the top, it didn't take a nuclear scientist to figure out we’d just screwed Curtis. He was surely a mile or two down the road now and we were a thousand feet above him, with nowhere else to go but back to where we started our climb. Brushing aside Scott’ s advice that we do just that, Matt and I stared down the mountain and saw what appeared to be only a large field of sagebrush between us and Old Italian Creek Road. About a half-mile down the mountain – probably could coast all the way, right? Theoretically, sure. The slope down the mountain was no problem, but the sagebrush suddenly became thicker and taller than it appeared from 1,000 feet away. We took turns riding blindly through the 4-foot brush, trying to find any sort of goat trail or gully where we could actually see what we were riding into. Eventually we found mud and flowing water, both of which were ill suited for any of us. We all made it down to Old Italian Creek Road, finally, but not before watching Scott disappear into a gully. The sagebrush had concealed a 10-foot drop-off, which Scott handled the way any normal dirtbike-addicted person would: he bailed off the bike and rolled down the side of the gully, thus preserving his 450EXC from a similar fate.
We rode our collective tails off toward American Flag Mountain, a peak we knew Curtis badly wanted to see. Along the way we stopped a group of riders who’d just descended the treacherous mountain trail and asked if there were any DR-Z400’s at the summit. Once we mentioned yellow fenders and a gas tank the size of Montana, they all nodded enthusiastically. They had, indeed, spotted The Supertanker, and it was magnificent. We began our climb.
Alas, there was no DRZ at the summit. We took photos, ate a snack and resigned ourselves to the certainty that Curtis was going to be an angry man the next time we saw him. With that, Matt and I decided it was time to torture Scott by leading him down the toughest singletrack we knew of in Taylor Park: Star Trail. We picked up the trailhead near the bottom of American Flag Mountain and assured Scott that since we would be riding the trail in reverse of the route Matt and I had taken the year before, Star Trail would be much easier in this direction.
A gullible man, that Scott Maxwell.
For about 2 minutes on Star Trail we had Scott believing what we’d told him. But any semblance of a smile left his face when we came upon the same hill Matt and I had slid down last year in the mud and I swore it would be impossible to climb. That would have been true, except this year the hill was bone-dry and a couple of alternate routes had materialized. Matt and I showed Scott the best line to the top, but he still wasn't entirely convinced it was possible, despite the two orange KTM’s parked 40 feet above him. With a little coaching and a push over a boulder or two, he made it up like a champ, later criticizing the trail designers for placing a boulder field immediately following a blind switchback. The nerve!
Scott had a chance to air his complaint to a pair of forest service workers repairing water breaks a mile or so later, but the sight of them performing manual labor with garden hoes (and with smiles to boot) on the side of the mountain probably effected all of our appreciative responses when they asked us to watch out for a team of mules on the trail. The mules were hauling concrete blocks to repair the nasty hill we’ d forced Scott to ascend, two and a half hours each way from the opposite side of Star Trail. I took off ahead of Matt and Scott and reached the mule team about 5 minutes before they did. A couple miles later, another team was being led by a gentleman whose cowboy demeanor spoke for itself when I expressed my admiration for the toughness of his mules. Dead silence, then realization that he was leading a team of horses. City people, sheesh.
At the trailhead, Scott burst out of the woods, ecstatic with relief. He had survived one of the toughest trails Colorado has to offer. When asked if he wanted to ride back to Three Rivers by way of Doctor’s Gulch, Scott replied, simply, “I cannot do that.” Probably a good idea, as we were all running low on fuel at that point. We headed for public roads and rode on gas fumes back to the cabin. The absence of Curtis at the cabin was met with a sense of dread, especially when we pooled our collective heads and realized he had no key to the front door. When he arrived an hour later, Curtis was oddly apologetic. Funny thing, he actually thought it was his mistake that got us separated. We let him go with that for awhile, but Scott’s conscience weakened first and he gradually let Curtis know that maybe we had something to do with his frantic all-afternoon search for us. He had in fact visited American Flag Mountain but left just minutes before we arrived. He’d traveled as far north as Crested Butte South, a community that is located (believe it or not) south of Crested Butte, to get gas (his tank hits reserve with 1.5 gallons still in it!) and finally arrived back at the cabin about 5 hours after we’d left him.
That night we took a break from the George Foreman grill graciously provided by Curtis and enjoyed $5 burgers at the bar next to the resort lodge, where Scott quizzed Sara the Waitress about her recent honeymoon to Norway. We discussed the fine art of protecting the general public from nuclear disasters and I learned more about nuclear plant operations than any corporate banker should ever know. During the week, so much nuclear power discussion took place that the whole trip could have been written off as a business expense.