Many types of brake rotors have graced the wheels of my motorcycles. As of today, the standard wavy kind which seem to come with most European bikes are fine by me, front and rear. But it wasn't always that way.
When I first began riding and racing, rotors were all perfectly round and came with holes drilled into the braking surface. Those holes helped cool the rotors, but they also turned the rotors into brake pad grinders in muddy conditions. The holes would fill with mud and work over the pads so much that one ride or race would be the end of them.
Solid rotors were designed to alleviate this issue, and they worked very well to extend pad life. The compromise was cooling. Solid rotors heated up more than drilled rotors.
During the peak of my Illinois mud riding days, I mostly used solid rear rotors. In an fit of extreme spending weakness, I even bought a spare front wheel for my KX250 and mounted a solid rotor, just for those horrible mud races that make short work of brake pads.
Then came wavy brake rotors. At first I thought the waves were just a goofy style gimmick. Then I bought a KTM with these rotors. I don't understand how or why the waves make brake pads last longer in muddy conditions, but they just do. Since then, I've never had a thought of changing a rotor on any motorcycle that came with the waves.
Oversized Rotors
For many years I scoured eBay for deals, and once found one in an oversized front rotor kit for my KX250. For $60 delivered to my door, I gave it a chance.
The kit came with the oversized rotor and a bracket that replaced the KX's stock caliper carrier. The bracket used the stock slider bolt and the little rubber booties. The bottom line is, it will stop you in a hurry. However, I can't say it was a huge improvement over the stock front brake, because the KX's brake was pretty good to begin with. For $60, compared to around $300 new, it was a good upgrade but I probably wouldn't buy one of these brand new. The only real downside is that these larger rotors aren't always compatible with rotor guards.